Peace at Last

We buried my uncle Addy last Sunday in a plot that my grandfather bought decades ago, a plot that I will also occupy when my days on earth are over. It was brilliantly clear and bundle-up cold but not bitter on the hillside of Sharon Gardens, an idyllic setting a few miles from where my parents live. That’s where they will be buried too, not now, not soon, but someday.

Addy died peacefully at 6:15 p.m. on New Year’s Day. Joyce and Bobby and Nancy held him and watched him breathe his last breath. In the past, when I’ve heard people say about their lost loved ones, “At least he’s at peace,” “Thank God she’s not suffering anymore,” or “He’s in a better place,” the words felt empty, as if rationalizing the trauma would dampen its impact.

But Addy was suffering, the chemo having failed, ultimately, to reverse the cancer; the medications having failed to shield him from pain; the onslaught of time and disease and what I gather is the natural order of life having impaired his eyesight and speech and physical strength. He was ready. Before he slipped away, he began to write his obituary with Joyce. It was his time.

When we celebrated his 85th birthday in early December, he was with it. Weak but with it. It was what a celebration should be—to his life, his friendships, his loving family. We sang skit songs, read poems, gave tributes, and remembered the happier times. We didn’t know how long he’d be around, but we knew it didn’t look good. The hugs were more precious, the jokes funnier, the appreciations more heartfelt. He knew. He took it in. He cried and laughed. We all did. It seemed the natural thing to do.

At his funeral service, people talked about Addy’s sweetness, his creativity, his musicality, and his even temper. My parents each reflected with humor and caring. I’d forgotten how active the four of them were, and the trips and cruises and bridge games they'd shared. My mind kept flashing forward, wondering who would be eulogizing my parents when their turn comes. No, don’t go there. Deep breathing grounded me back in the present and I cried for Addy. It wasn’t meant to be. But it was. What is the alternative? It’s the natural order of things.

Bobby spoke softly and lovingly, holding back tears with his sweet, sad smile. He had bathed and dressed and lifted and tended to Addy in his final weeks. When Nancy had joined the vigil, the three of them talked with Addy for as long as he could talk, sang with Addy for as long as he could sing, and shared their strength with one another. Joyce wasn’t ready. How can one ever be ready?

I wanted to share a eulogy, but I didn’t know what to say. So I convened a chorus instead. My brother Don, his wife Jo, their son Nick, and my friend Susan and I offered Gerald Cohen’s “Adonai Ro’i,” a sublime setting of the 23rd psalm, “The Lord Is My Shepherd.” Singing is the deepest expression of love and soul and comfort. Addy heard us. Or so I’d like to believe.

Last July, when my fellow Zamir singer Jody died, I wrote about the electric spark I experienced at her funeral. Carpe diem. Life is not a dress rehearsal. I felt freed up and intensely alive, no more wasting time, no more inertia or passivity. Life is short! Act now!

But at the cemetery, standing beside Addy’s grave, seeing his wooden casket with its carved Star of David already in the ground, I felt empty. Among the parent generation, Addy was the first to go. Now Joyce was a widow. What will happen next? We huddled together, family and friends, as the young cantor spoke kindly and prayed and chanted, including “Adonai Ro’i” and the traditional memorial prayer, “El Maley Rachamim,” or “God full of compassion.”

Just then, we saw Jeanne and her newborn baby, swaddled in pink, walking toward the site. I hadn’t seen Jo’s sister since she gave birth in October. A passing train whistled. The sun cast shadows across the snowy landscape. It was almost too poetic. The circle of birth and death, the inevitability of time and passage and life and loss.

We shoveled dirt onto the casket, one by one, tucking Addy in with a blanket of earth, as the cantor suggested. “OK, kid, here ya go,” said Joyce. The dirt smelled rich and deep and warm.

Life goes on. And with it, certain death. But when and how? With suffering or suddenness? No one knows. But I know Addy is at peace at last. God bless you, my dearest uncle. I love you very much.